44 special vs 45 colt. Feb 12, 2020 · HSM Bear Load .
44 special vs 45 colt I chr Oct 13, 2020 · A side by side comparison of two calibers firmly rooted in the American West – the 45 Long Colt vs. At the end of a match, I fired five 44-40 rounds out of one of my 45 Colt revolvers at a standard CAS pistol target at normal CAS pistol distance. Aug 9, 2009 · However, if you are using a Colt SAA size frame (this includes the New Vaquero and the . 38 Special and . 44 special and a model 25-5 (. 45 ACP rounds were developed in the USA within six years of each other. 56; 6. 45 Colt long after the introduction of the . Make mine 44 special. Specialty . 45 Colt Anaconda is the best gun. They shoot well with soft bullets that "fit". Apr 2, 2011 · Both the . 44 Special between the cartridge’s introduction and the SAA’s first demise in 1941. 44. maximum for . I’m not sure if . Bottom line, your shooting ability is far more important than which caliber you use, and you "Can take that to the bank!" Jun 23, 2024 · A detailed analysis of the two rimmed revolver cartridges, covering their history, performance, ballistics, and terminal effects. 40 vs . 45 Colt $45. 45 inches in diameter. 45 Colt will stomp all over a . 410 vs 20 Gauge; 22 LR vs 22 Mag; 6mm . 44 mag as well, then I They are two of the most popular revolver cartridges of all time, and today Brownells Gun Tech™ Steve Ostrem does a quick compare-and-contrast of the . Enter your email. 45 ACP is very comparable to the . 45 Colt is 14,000 PSI . The 45 colt will probably be more fun to shoot unless you like decentigrating objects. 8 Western vs 7mm Rem Mag vs . The point of all of this, is if you are going to compare the realities of the 44 Mag and 45 Colt, you have to consider the gun and the use and the shooter. 44 Specialkinda like, a gorgous Blonde and a gorgeous Brunette Different, yesbut, either way. 45LC for a Colt SAA 3rd Generation pistol. Colt Single Action Army revolvers were even more sparse as . Nov 18, 2023 · The . 45 torques my jaws as they cant get the chamber/bore specks right. Oct 3, 2024 · All beat the living hell out of the . Nov 3, 2012 · A forum thread where users share their opinions and experiences on the two revolver cartridges. 9 13. I made this loading block up when I first started shooting CAS. 45 Colt. 45 Colt carbines being offered for the first time. Feb 9, 2016 · Having said all that - I have single actions - "cowboy guns" - in 22 Long Rifle, 30 Carbine, 32 H&R Magnum, 38/357, 38-40, 41 Magnum, 44 Russian, 44 Special 44-40, 44 Magnum and 45 Colt. So really, your preference depends upon which model you're addressing. 357 Mag. 28 Nosler; 6. May 7, 2021 · That 45 Colt BCA Redhawk combined with our 365HH LFR load has proven to be a great heavy field gun as has my blue 5-1/2” Bowen/Rowen 44Mag Redhawk with our 330HH+P load. 44 Special, if he has a way to determine the pressure his loads develop. Handgun Recoil Table . comConsider becoming a Patron! / chukesoutdoor Send F TMJ vs FMJ; 44 Special Vs 44 Magnum; 45 90 vs 45 70; 6. Nov 17, 2014 · If your considering a single action revolver and are willing to reload your own, the 44 special Flattop Blackhawk would be the ticket. Lastly, the . By Chuck Hawks. 45 colt revolvers are usually able to take the pressures of . Many revolver manufacturers produce firearms chambered in both cartridges, offering a wide range of options in terms of size, style, and features. The modern sport of cowboy action shooting has resulted in . 45 Colt is my favorite cartridge, the . 45 colt, both in 4 3/4". 8 SPC vs 5. 45 Colt round with slow burning gun powder in a 24 inch barrel is superior to the . 45 Colt (LC Long Colt) rounds with a chart and examples. 44 Special? Nov 17, 2009 · Well, I don't see it as a vs. People are wrong. 45 Colt Ruger Vaqueros 5. 44 Special allows more metal around the cartridge and it can be loaded considerably hotter with safety. The common comparison of a Ruger single action in . Aug 29, 2017 · The bullet is approximately . 45 ACP vs 45 Colt. 44 Magnum is what most people consider to be the best of the “old-school” straight-walled cases. They are ok in . 240 grn 44 Special Data should be just about perfect Feb 12, 2020 · HSM Bear Load . For the 45 acp it's 230 HPs on top of a healty dose of Unique. 45 still won't show the true potential of the . Oct 30, 2016 · I am trying to justify buying Henry Big Boy 20 . While the recoil of his 300g loads is stout, it is not uncontrollable at all. 45 Colt against Model 73 in . Feb 8, 2015 · Check out the numbers for the . By he way, for anyone who thinks the . Testing out the Buffalo Bore Heavy . 38 Special bullet diameter is . 44-40. I also own 4 various s&ws in . 44 Special for one who did. 45 Colt cartridges are both are made for Handguns. Left to right in this photo, 45 Colt, 44-40, 38-40. 44 S&W Special and . 45 ACP are different cartridges with varying dimensions and cannot be used interchangeably without the risk of malfunction or damage to the firearm. I prefer the 44-40 more than the others, but second choice is 45 Colt. 6 2. 44 Magnum boasts . Although the 45 Long Colt can handle over 50% more powder than the 45 ACP, the 45 LC has a lower maximum pressure of 14,000 psi compared to 21,000 psi for 45 ACP as established by SAAMI. 3 days ago · Prioritize less recoil and easier handling: Choose the . However, the . 44 Special double-action revolver and the . com. 45 ACP and . Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing t Mar 2, 2016 · Shoot, I have been shooting 45 Colt in my pistols and 44-40 in my rifles since day one in SASS. 45 Colt cartridge by 157 feet per second. I spent money reaming cylinders, sending guns back to ruger, buying moulds and trying loads to get poor results in . Learn the differences and similarities between the . They both load easily. 44 Special has a definite advantage in power and strength of the revolver simply because the . May 2, 2020 · In this photo, left to right, the rounds are 45 Colt, 45 Schofield, 44-40 (44WCF), 44 Russian, 38-40 (38WCF), and 45-70. 45 ACP cartridge Chuke pts two revolvers against each other, a 44 magnum and a 45 Long Colt. Mar 24, 2019 · Although I perfer the 44 special as a revolver cartridge because it has a rim, I think the 45 acp might have an edge in the ability to be a better stopper because of its larger diameter. Yes we load for both. Jun 8, 2009 · Elmer Keith recommended . There's just something about that BIG hole and that BIG hunk of lead. 45 ACP or . Dec 24, 2024 · Both . 44-40 Winchester has a smaller diameter than the . 44 also used a heeled bullet, however, today’s . 44 Magnum, . 45 colt). Starting loads will be the same. 45 Colt round was far stronger - for general purposes - than the factory loaded . 45 Colt (sometimes called “Long Colt”) has been around since 1873. 44 Russian, were the premier Target Cartridges of the daythough this is merely ancillary if a short Barrel. 456" diameter cylinder throats as-pinned. Are . 44 Special shortened and with a smaller rim diameter. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction; that is one of the physical laws of our universe. 45 Colt (20 in. Every now and then a wad cutter type gets snagged on the flat shoulder if the shooter is a bit lazy on the leer. An interesting option is the S&W . And add another person in favor of handloading the 45 Colt. ALL THREE have . 44 Special are comparable to those of the . The 45 ACP and 44 Remington Magnum are two excellent handgun cartridge choices for self-defense. 44 special and . Now, in the Winchester 1892 or Marlin 1894, the . 5 inch (for SASS only) instead of buying just a Henry . Learn how these calibers differ in hunting, target shooting, and plinking applications. 9mm vs 40 vs 45. 45 Colt, then my preference would be for the . speeds. 198 . 45 Colt has more history and versatility with handloads, but the . 45 Colt (230; 936; 44) 7. 357”; the . 44 Special is a 200 gr HCWC rated at 1,000 FPS and the . 45 Colt and . 45 Colt, made in 1914, 1918 and 1920, respectively. PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE stop referring to the . Intended field load will be a 240-260 grain WFN at 900-1000 FPS for the . Super classy. It is a fun caliber to shoot. 357 Magnum. It isn’t necessary to place the revolver on half cock. 44 and a 280-300 grain WFN at the same velocity for the . " Either cartridge in standard loading is fun to shoot. While the . 44 Special is too weak, I suggest you look up Elmer Keith's history with a Colt Peacemaker chambered in . 45 Colt ammunition are relatively easy to find, though the availability of different bullet weights and types might vary depending on your location and retailer. Colt only made 506 chambered for . 44 Lipsey Special) then the . The latter was done to fit the first replica sixguns which had cylinders too small in Dec 7, 2018 · The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare . This is in part due to the 45 Colt's over sized case, but mainly due the fact that 45 Colt chambers are generally cut over size and the throats are often incorrectly sized as well. If you have a short-barrel . 45 Colt as "Long Colt". 44 or . 44 Special could be reloaded to higher pressures without blowing up the revolver. 44 Magnum, the . Below is the comprehensive list of ballistics comparisons between all of the most popular calibers for handgun, rifle, and rimfire ammunition. I have read that the modern . Handgun cartridges are divided into three major types: those intended for semi-automatic pistols, those to be used in revolvers, and those for single-shot pistols. 44 than in . I own colt SAA`s in . 44 Remington Magnum. com Winchester . In the 44 Special I'm using a 'Keith' hard cast SWC over a dollop of 2400. On the same platform its also lighter than the 357 maggie. 45. 45 ACP, a popular option for both law enforcement and civilian personal defense. 44 special is a sweet heart. 45 colt velocity and more with fine accuracy. 45 Colt are fine calibers in either a good Smith & Wesson or Ruger revolver. 44 Special. 45 Colt, and how they compare for hunting and defense. 44 Special in 1908. There are better ones today, but it certainly works OK. 44 Special/. This would perhaps give the handloader an advantage when reloading the . 44 Specials. 44 Special and the . Prepare for considerable dismay. Dec 7, 2018 · Compare the average velocity and energy of . 38 Special cartridge is slightly taller and skinnier than the . 5 Creedmoor; 22 Hornet vs 223; 6. Consider the availability of ammunition and reloading components: Both are widely available, but the . 45 Colt $46. Need maximum stopping power for hunting or self-defense and don't mind heavier recoil: Choose the . 475 Linebaugh 25 Yd Group rested w/2x Leupold A couple of other loads at 25 yd group Two groups on right are with 180gr Horn XTP at 25 yds. 45 Colt was introduced is 1873, and the 'Johnny come lately' . Final Shots: 44 Magnum vs 45 ACP. 429) Special. It is noteworthy that both Frank Hamer and Tom Threepersons carried the . A real thumper of its day. 44-40 Winchester and . Feb 9, 2014 · The . Paul May 25, 2020 · S&W 24/624 (post-WWII N-frames) and Ruger Blackhawks are both level III capable revolvers, and probably the ones that most people shooting heavy 44 special loads will be using (I would not recommend these loads in any five-chambered revolvers (including the GP100) or Colts or Colt clones). 44 Special were made and exactly 1,200 of the fixed sight Model 1950 Military were made. That is until you bring the 45 colt up to 44mag power levels. Yes, #42798 is the traditional . I recall the S&W advertisement on the 44 Special: "The 44 Special cartridge gives it all the muzzle energy and shock power of the 45, but with far greater accuracy and ranging power. 44 Special like a 624 or 24-3 with a 250 grain cast Lyman #429421 behind Skeeter's old load of 7. Testing out the Buffalo Bore hard cast wadcutters in . Some prefer the 44 Special for accuracy, others the 45 Colt for versatility and availability. 45 Colt in a "big game" dangerous animal ballistic test. Jun 7, 2012 · The 44 special can do anything the 357 can & if need be, its a bigger hammer if things get out of hand. New model flat top ,44 specials have shot like they had eyes for me. 44-40 can be loaded to higher pressures than are safe in the 73 Winchester. Typically, the 45 shoots a slightly heavier bullet. 99 Cabelas. Shoot over chronograph. https://www. Nov 18, 2007 · For off the shelf (non-custom) equipment the 44 Special will generally be more accurate than the 45 Colt. 44 mag, but I would think not as of now. 8 SPC; 50 Beowulf vs 50 BMG; 26 Nosler vs 6. 4 15. . Apr 26, 2024 · On this episode of Ultimate Barrier Testing, we will be comparing the performance of the 45 Colt to the 44 Special and the 44 Magnum on 4 different targets. 44 Special (Upper Right is 6" m83 . 285 inch case. 44 special only compared to . Colt in . 45 Colt will always be the big brother of the smaller . They can both do a number on target. 44-40 bullet. The remaining 10%? It can be accomplished too … in capable hands. 44 Special in terms of energy, but when it comes to run-of-the-mill loads, they’re fairly close. With the added groove, the iconic Winchester and Marlin lever action rifles could feed and extract the . Between 1950 and 1966 only 5,050 of the Model 1950 Target . 45 Colt as the cylinder walls are thinner in the . So, there you have it mild to wild, light to heavy -- my M97 . Everyone knows which I prefer for most of my revolver shooting. 9mm vs 45 ACP. 5 grains of Unique against a whitetail buck. I use a lot of Clear Ballistics and 1/2" MDF. 44 (. This specific round is used solely in revolvers, and is an extremely historic round. The special can easily duplicate bp . It's just a larger cartridge, no two ways about it. 45 Auto ACP ammo rounds. 8 SPC vs 6. If you’re specifically asking about . 45 Colt bullet mass at . IMHO either one will make a fine rifle. 45 Colt The . Nov 1, 2019 · I have three Colt New Service revolvers in . If you are looking at collector value, maybe the . 45 colt. For instance I have S&Ws in 24-3 and 25-5. 44 Magnum 44 Special 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460 Magnum 480 Ruger 50 AE 500 In contrast, the . So, what is the mystical attraction to the . I tested this a bunch of years ago. I can assure you, a 44-40 looks a lot more like a 45 Colt than 38-40 does. 44 Special will have manageable recoil and still have plenty of power to get the job done. 45 Colt, though it is truly the magnum version of the . 45 Colt is a 225 May 13, 2024 · No, the . Developed by Elmer Keith from the . 44 Special, heir to the repute of . Similar to the . 45 Colt might offer slightly more options due to its longer history. Oct 10, 2023 · But the “45 Colt” and the “45 Long Colt,” or “45 LC,” are the same cartridge, whereas the “45 Colt” and “45 Auto” are not the same. If you include . But can the Special effectively stop a dangerous threat? The ballistics of the . Our 45 Colt Winchester (jap) feeds most cast well. Granted, the . 45 ACP bullet diameter is . 45 Long Colt are two of the most iconic cartridges in American history. 44 Special, the . 44 S&W Special vs . 45 Automatic. 45 Colt if you prefer a revolver. 44-40 Winchester cartridge has a higher muzzle velocity than the . Aug 9, 2009 · I have always had a warm place in my heart for both the . 452” The . 44 Colt but these also have been changed from the original. Apr 15, 2020 · Not to be a wet blanket, but Universal is one of the worst powders for large case, low pressure rounds like 45 Colt and 44 Special. 5 Grendel; 6. 44-40 Winchester cartridge has a longer length than the . Caliber . 25" S&W model 69 VS the Buffalo Bore Anti-Personnel . 460 XVR. 45 Colt loads will do better than the . 44 Remington Magnum. 44 Magnum. The 45 Schofield is slightly shorter and slightly larger in diameter. 45 Colt by 0. 606 Get special offers delivered right to your inbox. Aug 2, 2015 · In a stronger gun, the . The usability of any caliber lies in its blend of precision, energy transfer, and ballistic capabilities. chukesoutdoor. Sep 6, 2019 · The 45 Colt will give the opportunity of firing much heavier cast. Aug 16, 2009 · I love the Scoefield. A Winchester rifle and a revolver in 44 40 was a very useful combination. Notice the 45 Colt, 44-40, and 38-40 are all approximately the same length. 44 Special and . 9mm vs 40 vs 45; 45 ACP vs 45 Colt; Final Shots: 44 Magnum vs 45 ACP. If you like the power, performance, and just plain enjoyment of large revolvers, two of your finest ammo options are the . 5 PRC; 28 Gauge vs 410; 6. The rise of Cowboy Action Shooting (CAS) in the 1980s breathed new life into the sales of guns chambered in the . 44 Special, with its mild recoil and more limited penetration, is a safer choice for home defense. The Smith & Wesson 44 Special vs the Colt 45 ACP. Oct 24, 2007 · Maximum SAAMI spec for . Jan 12, 2009 · For a Revolver, . Jun 4, 2016 · The common wisdom is that if you fire a 44-40 in a 45 Colt revolver, the bullet will rattle down the bore and not hit anything. The 45 will nudge things out of the way with a vengeance and the 44mag will pulverize things. Jun 16, 2023 · Both the . . Historically, it was never chambered in rifles. I have both and have lots of respect for them both. com Dec 14, 2017 · A user asks for opinions on choosing between . 44 special. 8 Western vs 6. 44 Special 190 gr LSWCHP from my 4. ) (for SASS only) and two . Dec 18, 2021 · 45 Schofield on the left, 44 Special on the right. 45 slugs are Nov 17, 2018 · Lower left gun is a 5 1/2" M97 . While I do not own a 45 Colt BH myself, I have shot Iron Mike Golf's 5½" BH with everything from cowboy loads to 300g XTPs over 21 or 22 grains of H110. Otherwise, you're comparing apples to potential hand grenades. 45 Colt, but to me, there is something to be said about using a modern . 45 Long Colt and the . 44 special likes them all. 45 version, but in my personal experience will favor the . 45 Long Colt the Same? The . 45 Colt on the front line were many. 024 inches. 454 casull then as well and still shoot . Can pick up a . The . 44 Special holds a dear spot in my heart. Wow, that's a match up for sure right thar !!! All the old timers knew about those cartridges and the handgun that shoot 'em. 44 Colt cartridge is simply the . Jun 6, 2009 · For me it boils down to the make and model of gun. 44 Special was the preferred cartridge for this task, as there were more varied projectiles made for it, and the revolvers of the day—such as the S&W Triple Lock, Colt New Service and SAA—had thicker cylinder walls in . In Black Powder days, cartridges were completely filled with powder, so the relative size of the cartridge was a good indicator of relative power. Compare all 44 Special ammunition manufacturers on one easy to read chart. Plus bigger holes are always better on game. 45 ACP for a Revolver, use full Moon Clips, very elegant. 45 Colt and the . Feb 27, 2024 · 45 Colt vs 44 Mag: Understanding the Ballistic Performance and Technicalities. This is perhaps one of the biggest differences between the two cartridges: the 45 Colt cartridge was designed to use black powder while the 45 ACP was designed Sep 9, 2022 · The . The 357 or 38 special loaded in the +P range can be quite loud, the 44 special isn't nearly as bad if you have to take a couple of quick shots without hearing protection. Those using the . Other users share their experiences, preferences and advice on reloading, accuracy and availability of the two calibers. Colt’s first . And one other thing. 45 Long Colt - The premier revolver cartridge of the black powder era, it remained our most powerful handgun cartridge until the advent of the . Oct 20, 2020 · A Colt pattern gun in 44 special would be more practical than 44-40 and serve you well. 45 Colt (255 LFP; 914; 44) 10. The Ruger’s loading gate may be opened with the hammer down. A model 29-2 and one of those flat top lipsey rugers in . 44 Special vs . Both are solid choices. 5/5 - (79 vote) Categories FAQ We can purchase sixguns today chambered in . The . 44 Mag Aug 16, 2009 · I love the Scoefield. 38 Special has a longer overall length than the . 410 vs 12 Gauge. 38 Special, though, which generates energies in the low 200s. 45 Colt case had been modified with an extractor groove making it possible to use in rifles. Testing the Underwood hard cast . They both fire heavy bullets that have been proven as combat-effective from the battlefields of Europe, the South Pacific, and the concrete jungle as well. His thinking was the factory loaded . 45 Colt for one who didn't reload and . Apr 30, 2020 · . 45 Colt 225 gr LSWCHP from my S&W Dec 19, 2010 · I am into fairly light handy revolvers. Both cartridges were developed in the 19th century and were used by some of the most famous firearms in history, including the Colt Single Action Army and the Winchester Model 1873. Using available 45 ACP and with the ability to eventually reload the 45 Colt. However, the 44 special can be loaded at higher velocities and pressures then the 45 acp. 44 Special is 15,500 PSI. Fire five shots with powder near primer, then powder near bullet. If your going to use factory ammo, I would say the Black hawk convertible in 45 Colt/45 ACP would be the most useful. I like them both. Jun 18, 2002 · So, you have to discuss Model 73 in . 45 ACP; The . 44 Special is perfect for about 90% of any daily task. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or Aug 30, 2012 · There are a bunch of 44 special aficionados out there. 45 Long Colt is fired from a 1. My intended use of this pistol is as a range gun/plinker and as a backup while hog/deer hunting. 5 PRC. 44 mag as well, then I Can pick up a . 455 Eley, . See full list on barreldata. The advantage of the 44-40 vs 45 Colt in the old west was the ammo could be used in both your rifle and your handgun. Understanding the technicalities of these aspects can give an insight into the feedback you hear from those shooting the 45 Colt or the 44 Mag. Provided both are loaded a factory velocities. The 24-3 has the pencil barrel (44 special) and the 25-5 has the heavy straight barrel. 44 Magnum is, essentially, the magnum version of the . 44 Special, of course. 44 Magnum 20 inch (for SASS only). bpsofob zwbumz ibfe hgufg vrdua plbm dlv fekucy vgh guex